Last Updated December 17, 2020 12/17/2020

Top 12 Vacation Rentals in NYC for Attending a Broadway Show

Our research is editorially independent but we may earn a commission for purchases made through our links.

Broadway refers to a cluster of theaters in New York. There are dozens of establishments to see the glitz and talents of one of these spectacular shows. Simply put, there’s nothing quite like it. It’s safe to say this experience alone warrants a trip to the Big Apple, which offers a long list of must-see attractions.

When it comes to finding a place to stay, you want to be close to all of the top theaters in Midtown, while also being close to great restaurants. And that’s not hard to do, but we have found the ones we think are the best.

YOU'RE ALL SET!

Look out for our newsletters in your inbox soon.

Advertisement
Modern 1 Bedroom with Marble Bathroom Modern 1 Bedroom 4FL w/Marble Bthr
Credit: Airbnb.com
Modern 1 Bedroom 4FL w/Marble Bthr

Modern 1 Bedroom with Marble Bathroom

Modern aesthetics give the space a refined character. A sleek kitchen, comfy sleeping spaces, and an overall crisp, new appeal come together in this small but well-equipped dwelling. Guests find that there is just enough room to relax and not feel overwhelmed.

Mint House At 70 Pine Mint House At 70 Pine
Credit: airbnb.com
Mint House At 70 Pine

Mint House At 70 Pine

For those looking for something completely modern and luxurious, there is this incredible listing within an art deco skyscraper. Inside is artistic and lit with a moody tone. On-site is a craft coffee bar that will make the best lattes some might have ever tasted.

Vintage Loft Style Studio - Greenwich/Union Square Vintage Loft Style Studio - Greenwich/Union Square
Credit: Airbnb.com
Vintage Loft Style Studio - Greenwich/Union Square

Vintage Loft Style Studio - Greenwich/Union Square

Vintage is the theme of this high ceiling apartment. A huge bonus is that the space is also tucked far away from the street, so is extra quiet. Especially for New York City! So if you’ve been out and about and are totally exhausted this is the place to get a good night’s sleep. Two generously sized beds are available within the lovely space.

Fabulous Loft Studio in Gramercy Fabulous Loft Studio in Gramercy
Credit: Airbnb.com
Fabulous Loft Studio in Gramercy

Fabulous Loft Studio in Gramercy

The set up in this Airbnb is a ton of fun. Plenty of windows allow light into the adorable living space, and a tiny ladder leads up to a loft that houses the bed. It’s much lower off the ground than your typical loft, so should be slightly more accessible than the traditional versions.

Amazing Views in The Heart of Time Square Amazing Views in The Heart of Time Square
Credit: airbnb.com
Amazing Views in The Heart of Time Square

Amazing Views in The Heart of Time Square

Imagine how spectacular it would be to return to an apartment that overlooks Times Square! And the Hudson river! While all of our locations are optimal, we aren’t sure if it gets better than this. Just go down the stairs and have access to the best transportation in the city.

Spacious One Bedroom Near Central Park Spacious One bedroom near Central Park
Credit: Airbnb.com
Spacious One bedroom near Central Park

Spacious One Bedroom Near Central Park

Maybe it’s the small kitchen and breakfast nook, or possibly the rustic wooden floors. Either way, there is something incredibly cozy about this little apartment. Take a stroll around Central Park which is very close. Then head to your evening show.

Fifth Avenue Ultra Luxurious Large 3 Bedroom - Domenico Vacca Building Fifth Avenue Ultra Luxurious Large 3 Bedroom - Domenico Vacca Building
Credit: VRBO.com
Fifth Avenue Ultra Luxurious Large 3 Bedroom - Domenico Vacca Building

Fifth Avenue Ultra Luxurious Large 3 Bedroom - Domenico Vacca Building

We decided to bring you something totally glam. This apartment is absolutely elegant and breathtaking. High ceilings and bright colors are met with touches of glistening metal and gorgeous wooden flooring. We can picture how glamorous it would feel to return from a dazzling Broadway show with a bottle of champagne and some fancy takeout!

Stylish Stay with Private Balcony Stylish Stay with Private Balcony
Credit: airbnb.com
Stylish Stay with Private Balcony

Stylish Stay with Private Balcony

Sometimes we just don’t need that much. Sitting well under $100 a night, this pick is not only budget-friendly but really cute! Enjoy a small patio with seating, and a comfortable place to sleep. Little touches like the Statue of Liberty silhouette are just the cherry on top.

Stylish 1 Bedroom Apartment in Chelsea Central & Stylish 1 Bedroom Apt - Heart of Chelsea
Credit: Airbnb.com
Central & Stylish 1 Bedroom Apt - Heart of Chelsea

Stylish 1 Bedroom Apartment in Chelsea

It’s simple, and it’s super clean, making it a great option when visiting New York. Because let’s be honest, how much time are you really going to spend in your hotel room or vacation rental? Not a lot when given all there is to explore! But there’s a place to prep food, living space, and separated sleeping.

Sun Filled Artist Soho Loft Sun Filled Artist Soho Loft
Credit: Airbnb.com
Sun Filled Artist Soho Loft

Sun Filled Artist Soho Loft

Find your inner peace at this open and uplifting apartment. Traditional architecture adorns the exterior of the building, and guests will feel like they are immersing in some of New York’s most significant past times. Being in a quiet walkable location, a trendy café with a killer latte is a short jaunt from the building.

Central Park Nest, High Above The Trees Central Park Nest, High Above The Trees
Credit: Airbnb.com
Central Park Nest, High Above The Trees

Central Park Nest, High Above The Trees

Come snuggle up in this ambient space. Inside you will find intricate decor and an overall welcoming feel. All of the art on the walls is unique while adding that special touch to the space. But the most appealing aspect would be the views of Central Park! Literally, it’s right there, and it’s completely and totally amazing.

Cozy, Quintessential Brooklyn Carriage House Cozy, Quintessential Brooklyn Carriage House
Credit: Airbnb.com
Cozy, Quintessential Brooklyn Carriage House

Cozy, Quintessential Brooklyn Carriage House

This one may be a little bit further away, but given that New York has a wonderful transportation vein, the trip might be worth it to you. The setting is an old carriage house, that has been brightened and given an adorable bohemian flair. Enjoy the peace that comes along with this quaint cottage, and find that perfect balance between city life and serenity.

You May Also Like
16 Most Romantic Vacation Rentals in the U.S. By CHARITY DE SOUZA | FEB 05, 2021

Powered by: Strive Media

YOU'RE ALL SET!

Look out for our newsletters in your inbox soon.

Oops!

Please fill out highlighted fields and click "Compare Prices" to continue.