Our research is editorially independent but we may earn a commission for purchases made through our links.

Top 10 Dreamy Airbnb Rentals in Nantucket

A trip to Nantucket feels like escaping to your own little world, a place where time slows down and romance is always in the air. This little island off the coast of Massachusetts has been a favorite destination among vacationers for generations, with quaint hotels and outstanding restaurants to enjoy. But you can experience Nantucket in a truly modern and interesting way by renting an Airbnb property for your stay. Here are the best Airbnb rentals in Nantucket to get you dreaming about your next iconic adventure.

Sweet Dreams Romantic Guest Cottage Welcome home to your very own Nantucket cottage
Credit: Welcome home to your very own Nantucket cottage by Airbnb.com

Sweet Dreams Romantic Guest Cottage

You can stay in this highly rated Airbnb guesthouse known as Sweet Dreams, which is a two-story, free-standing building next to the host’s home. It comes with a gas grill on the patio, beach chairs and towels, central A/C and heat, and TV with DVD player. This is an awesome honeymoon cottage for two people. It’s easy to rent bikes or a car and get around when you stay here. Just a few minutes away, you’ll find restaurant and grocery store options. The place offers one bedroom, one bathroom, a kitchen, and free parking.

Room in Stunning Cottage with Pool and Ocean Views So inviting to take a dip on a warm day
Credit: So inviting to take a dip on a warm day by Airbnb.com

Room in Stunning Cottage with Pool and Ocean Views

For an amazing location and sparkling pool, travelers love this private room in a house that’s listed on Airbnb. It’s located in Tom Nevers and about a 15-minute drive from town. But from here, you’ll be within walking distance to the best island beaches. The home is called “Pinch Me” and comes with a heated lap pool, stone patio, and outdoor grill. Other fun perks of staying in the room are access to the kitchen, living room, and home gym in the basement. It’s a high-end luxury home you’ll love being in during your island trip.

Nantucket Guest Cottage Enjoy a beautiful day with time outdoors
Credit: Enjoy a beautiful day with time outdoors by Airbnb.com

Nantucket Guest Cottage

One of the many wonderful cottages to rent in Nantucket is this one-bedroom, one-bathroom space for up to four people. It’s an entire guesthouse for rent known as Casa di Limone. It has a lovely private garden and is located in the historic district on Main Street. Living history, fine dining, and great beaches are all close by. The place offers a king-size bed, kitchen, Wi-Fi, TV with standard cable, backyard, and air conditioning. It’s in a “best of both worlds” location because it’s close to town while also on a quiet section the street.

"Upon a Rock" Peace & Quiet – Mid-Island Retreat Light and airy for a restful stay
Credit: Light and airy for a restful stay by Airbnb.com

"Upon a Rock" Peace & Quiet – Mid-Island Retreat

Two travelers will enjoy staying at this Airbnb that has one bedroom and 1.5 baths. It’s a guest suite in a separate wing of the host’s main house and separated by a locked door. You’ll have your own private entrance, as well as beach chairs and towels to use. There is another Airbnb rental inside this same home. However, the amenities offered include Wi-Fi, laundry machines, TV with standard cable, and free parking.

Nantucket Carriage House Prepare meals to enjoy for your convenience
Credit: Prepare meals to enjoy for your convenience by Airbnb.com

Nantucket Carriage House

Here’s a new one-bedroom carriage house apartment for two people visiting Nantucket. This is a very highly rated rental because it’s close to beaches and the brewery, and it’s centrally located for a convenient stay in Nantucket. The bedroom here has a queen-size bed. Amenities include a kitchen, laundry machines, fridge, air conditioning, Wi-Fi, TV, and free parking.

Charming Nantucket Cottage Festive and fun for your Nantucket trip
Credit: Festive and fun for your Nantucket trip by Airbnb.com

Charming Nantucket Cottage

This is another tiny house option and one that accommodates three guests in two bedrooms and one bath. It’s a 400-square-foot space that is charming and has a nautical vibe. It gets great guest reviews and is conveniently located to make use of the town shuttle stops. The cottage has a kitchen that’s equipped with a fridge, coffee machine, microwave, and small stove. There’s also a living room and a small patio outside. One bedroom has a queen-size bed, and the other one has a single bed. Wi-Fi, TV, air conditioning, and free parking are also available.

Charming A-Ced Cottage for Two in 'Sconset Center New England charm is all yours here
Credit: New England charm is all yours here by Airbnb.com

Charming A-Ced Cottage for Two in 'Sconset Center

This adorable cottage for two people is available on Airbnb and beautifully decorated. It has a queen-size bed, dining room table and chairs, country antique décor, a flat-screen TV, full kitchen, Wi-Fi, and laundry machines. The rental property is on the eastern end of the island and right on the ocean. It’s fun to be here if you want to bike or walk everything on the island. That’s because there are restaurants, the beach, and stores within walking distance, as well as the main stop for the bus. Bikes are not offered onsite but can be rented in town.

Sailboat on the Harbor Embrace the Nantucket vibe with a boat Airbnb
Credit: Embrace the Nantucket vibe with a boat Airbnb by Airbnb.com

Sailboat on the Harbor

On Nantucket Harbor and on private mooring, you’ll find this Hunter 27-foot boat called “Happy Together.” Up to five people can stay on this boat Airbnb that offers a camping-style experience rather than a very luxurious stay. It’s basically a tiny house on the water and perfect for adventurous travelers. It offers something unique for your stay in Nantucket and has a toilet and sink operated by pumps. The showers are on the dock and not onboard the boat. Your group will be the only people onboard the boat during your stay. Since this is a boat on the water, your reservation could be affected by weather.

Walk to Beach – Cisco Studio Apartment A bright and cheery space for you to chill
Credit: A bright and cheery space for you to chill by Airbnb.com

Walk to Beach – Cisco Studio Apartment

An apartment rental in Nantucket to consider is this Airbnb option that’s a studio space for one or two people. It’s a 600-square-foot studio with a ¾ bath, mini kitchen, seating area, TV, and queen-size bed. The space is located over the host’s garage. Couples looking for a quiet place to stay enjoy it here. Your rental comes with beach towels and beach chairs. When you stay in this quiet neighborhood, the South Shore Cisco Beach will be just about one-third of a mile away.

Mid-Island Crash Pad Relax in your own quiet space
Credit: Relax in your own quiet space by Airbnb.com

Mid-Island Crash Pad

This is a conveniently located Airbnb that offers a studio space for two guests. It has one bed and one bath in a simple and affordable place. You’ll be in a basement studio space that you’ll access with a lock box. The hosts can give you as much privacy as you want or provide suggestions of things to see and do. Amenities provided include high-speed Wi-Fi, private bath, hair dryer, mini-fridge, and coffee maker. The property is on a quiet cul-de-sac road.

Travel Deals

Hotel Greystone Miami Beach | Up To 25% Off

$150+

14-Day Spitsbergen Photography Cruise

$8552+

13-Day Italian Vistas Tour | Save Up To $200

$3899+

Discover Seadust Cancun All-Inclusive Family Resort

$167+ pp/pn

$550 Off use DHPRT550 | Air & 10-Day Portugal Tour

$1899+

Air & 8-Day Iceland Fully-Guided Tour w/ 4 Activities

$1499+

Dominican Republic | Hyatt Ziva Cap Cana All-Incl. Resort

$444+ pp/pn

12-Day Spitsbergen Explorer Cruise | Save Up To 40%

$6452+

16-Day Portugal & Spain Tour | Save Up To $400

$4399+

New Jamaica Resort Opens 5/4 | Riu Palace Aquarelle

$139+ pp/pn

Air & 9-Day Scotland Tour w/ 4 Excursion Options

$3499+

GRAND OPENING - New All-Inclusive Jamaica Resort

$139+ pp/pn

MADE Hotel New York | Save Up To 15%

$225+

7-Nt Canada/New England Norwegian Cruise w/ Credit

$499+

Mexico | Hyatt Ziva Puerto Vallarta All-Inclusive Resort

$296+ pp/pn