Top 14 Lake House Vacation Rentals in New York

Our research is editorially independent but we may earn a commission for purchases made through our links.

When many people think of planning a trip to New York, images of big-city excitement and bright lights come to mind. However, the state of New York is also filled with beautiful destinations, including lakes that can get you back in touch with nature and really soothe the soul. Lake house vacation rentals here are plentiful and might be just what you need to relax and recharge. Here are our favorite New York lake house vacation properties to rent via Airbnb and Vrbo.

Enchanting Modern Farmhouse House on the Lake, Ferndale
Airbnb.com
Lots of space here for your favorite people

Enchanting Modern Farmhouse House on the Lake, Ferndale

This is a modern farmhouse with lake access and a pool for up to 10 people in New York. The home has four bedrooms, six beds, and two baths. It also comes with fast Wi-Fi, workspaces in two separate offices, and a two-car garage. With this lake house rental, you’ll be on a 3.88-acre property with great views and easy swimming access. The picnic area, including the pool, is only open when it’s warm outside, usually by late May. However, Indian Lake is great for not only fishing and swimming in the summer but also ice skating in the winter.

Brand New Lake Adirondack Rustic Chalet, Indian Lake
Airbnb.com
So close to the lake for year-around fun

Brand New Lake Adirondack Rustic Chalet, Indian Lake

You’ll love this lake house that sleeps up to eight people in New York. It has five bedrooms and 2.5 baths with a rustic vibe. The property is 20 minutes from hiking trails and Gore Mountain. While lake house rentals are most popular in the summer, it’s also fun to stay here in the winter to ice skate on Indian Lake, sled at the ski center, and use the hosts’ snowshoes and cross-country skis. Another perk of this rental is the laundry area in the basement, which also has a pool table and foosball table. This Airbnb has Wi-Fi.

Lake George Private Waterfront Property, Pilot Knob
Vrbo.com
Lake George Private Waterfront Property

Lake George Private Waterfront Property, Pilot Knob

You can also experience the best of Lake George with this lake house rental that sleeps up to 10 people. It is a 2,100-square-foot home with three bedrooms. You’ll be in an east shore property with great sunset views here. It’s a quiet place to stay that’s perfect for family dinners prepared in the country kitchen. Your rental here comes with a canoe and stand-up paddleboards to use but plan to bring your own life vests. Pets are not allowed here, and linens and towels are not provided. There’s an indoor water park and factory outlet stores just a short drive from the property.

Spectacular Lake Views From Every Room, Greenwood Lake
Airbnb.com
Easy, breezy, and loved by guests

Spectacular Lake Views From Every Room, Greenwood Lake

Here’s a highly rated Airbnb rental where you can look out to the lake, mountains, and gardens from every room. It’s an ideal spot for up to four people and has two bedrooms, three beds, and 1.5 baths. Listen to the soothing sounds of the seasonal waterfall and enjoy access to a private community beach. The Appalachian Trail is also close by for hiking. In the winter, people enjoy staying here to go skiing nearby, cuddle up by the fireplace, and relax in the clawfoot tub.

Swan Lake Paradise with Amenities Galore, Swan Lake
airbnb.com
Swan Lake Paradise with Amenities Galore

Swan Lake Paradise with Amenities Galore, Swan Lake

Take a vacation to Swan Lake and stay at this cozy lake home with a 12-person hot tub and heated saltwater swimming pool. The home sleeps up to eight people and has three bedrooms, six beds, and 2.5 baths. Guests enjoy the wrap-around terrace that looks out over the lake and going fishing and kayaking here from your own private boat launch. For entertainment, there are casinos, restaurants, a racetrack, and Bethel Woods just minutes away.

Lake George Waterfront with Awesome Sunsets, Ticonderoga
Vrbo.com
How wonderfully relaxing is this lakeside scene?

Lake George Waterfront with Awesome Sunsets, Ticonderoga

Spanning 2,400 square feet, this three-bedroom, 2.5-bath lake house sleeps nine people in New York. You’ll get to experience Lake George when you stay here and soak up the amazing views of the lake. The home has 150 feet of water frontage and a large dock. The outdoor space features a patio, fire pit, a canoe, five kayaks, paddles, and life jackets for guests to use. The home also has a laundry room and a playroom with ping pong and foosball. This Vrbo lake house is kid-friendly.

Lovely Cottage with Lakeside Patio & Dock, Homer
Vrbo.com
An adorable spot along the lake

Lovely Cottage with Lakeside Patio & Dock, Homer

Available to rent on Vrbo, this 1,200-square-foot cottage sleeps seven people and has three bedrooms, four beds, and one bath. It’s a cute lake house rental with stainless-steel appliances, a front porch with a ramp, internet, TV, board games, and laundry machines. Families with young children can stay here and use the twin bed and pack-and-play for little ones. The lakefront area has a picnic table, chairs, and fire pit to enjoy some fishing and swimming in the water. Nearby, you’ll find ski centers, nature centers, and great hiking.

1939 Log Cabin on Gorgeous Lake George, Silver Bay
Vrbo.com
1939 Log Cabin on Gorgeous Lake George

1939 Log Cabin on Gorgeous Lake George, Silver Bay

Log cabins make unique lake house rental options, such as this one that’s cute and quaint for up to five people. It’s a 450-square-foot cabin with five beds in a studio space and one bathroom. The host’s grandfather built this cabin in 1939 and has kept the space simple so it feels like taking a step back in time. There is some cell phone reception and Wi-Fi but no TV, computer, or dishwasher. Instead, spend your days relaxing here after fun outings filled with boating, fishing, and hiking. The host provides kayaks for guests to use.

Quiet Upstate NY Waterfront Lakehouse, Bradford
Airbnb.com
Perfect for preparing meals to enjoy by the lake

Quiet Upstate NY Waterfront Lakehouse, Bradford

Six or fewer people can book this Airbnb lake house and enjoy a peaceful getaway or an extended stay to work remotely. It’s on lovely Lamoka Lake and a beautiful place to watch sunsets and explore the Finger Lakes region of New York. The wine trails are less than 10 miles from here. The home has an expansive front yard and deck that you’ll enjoy spending time on. Pets are welcome to join you at this home for a $200 fee per stay.

Modern Secluded Lake House 35 Miles from NYC, Monroe
Airbnb.com
Comfy seating and lots of natural light coming in

Modern Secluded Lake House 35 Miles from NYC, Monroe

For a modern lake house retreat in a secluded forest, consider this conveniently located Airbnb with a private deck. It accommodates 10 guests and has three bedrooms and two baths. For fun here, there’s ping pong, foosball, kayaks, a canoe, paddleboards, hammocks, and outdoor seating. The home also comes with laundry machines, an open kitchen, and fireplaces for cozy weekends year-round. Pets are allowed to join you at this waterfront rental.

Spectacular Views of Ashokan Reservoir and Catskills, West Hurley
Vrbo.com
Spectacular Views of Ashokan Reservoir and Catskills

Spectacular Views of Ashokan Reservoir and Catskills, West Hurley

Here’s a 2,400-square-foot lake house in New York that offers three bedrooms, seven beds, and 2.5 baths. It has great views of the Ashokan Reservoir and Catskills, and it even comes with a hot tub to soak and gaze up at the stars at night. The home comes with new appliances and radiant floor heating. You’ll often see wildlife in the vicinity, including bald eagles and wild turkeys. The center of Woodstock is about eight miles from the home.

Gorgeous Garrison Lake House Near NYC, Garrison
airbnb.com
Gorgeous Garrison Lake House Near NYC

Gorgeous Garrison Lake House Near NYC, Garrison

You won’t have to travel far from NYC for rest and relaxation at this lake house. It sleeps four people and has two queen bedrooms, a full kitchen, dining area, screened porch, and one bathroom. The home does not have laundry access. It’s fun to have your own lakefront property here with lots of peace and quiet. You can access the Appalachian Trail in the neighborhood for hiking. Pets are not allowed here. Some extended stays and weekday stays are discounted.

The Pudding Pad Lake House, Putnam Valley
Airbnb.com
Gather around for a lakeside meal

The Pudding Pad Lake House, Putnam Valley

This lakehouse is also close to NYC and a great place for couples looking to escape city life. It’s a serene home that was built in 1969 and has a minimal vibe. You’ll be close to Fahnestock State Park for hiking and a beach. Up to four people can stay here, and dogs are welcome with a $50 pet fee per stay. One bedroom has a king-size bed, and the other has a queen-size bed. The space also offers Wi-Fi, and kitchen, and free parking.

Camp Caroga - Adirondack Lake House, Caroga Lake
airbnb.com
Camp Caroga - Adirondack Lake House

Camp Caroga - Adirondack Lake House, Caroga Lake

To enjoy a trip to West Caroga Lake, book this Airbnb lake house for up to 11 people. It’s just a short walk to a private sandy beach and a fun area to be in for hiking trails, restaurants, live music, and relaxation. The property is an hour from Saratoga Springs, Albany, and Utica. Although the home isn’t technically a waterfront property, the private beach is just a short walk away. You can also walk to a few restaurants from the house. Make sure to bring your own sheets and towels here.

Travel Deals

Vail | Book Direct for Best Rates + Cash Back Rewards

$170+

Air & 16-Day Thailand Tour | Save Up To $300

$2399+

Air & 4-Day All-Inclusive Cancun Boutique Resort

$525+

Fiji: Your Easy Island Escape w/ Nonstop R/T Flights

$899+

7-Day United Kingdom Guided Tour w/ Stonehenge

$1979+

9-Day Portuguese Escape w/ Wine & Tapas Tastings

$1299+

35' Keystone RV Springdale 303BH

$140+

Air & 12-Day France Tour | Save Up To $100

$3599+

7-Nt 3 Continents Cruise - Visit Europe, Asia & Africa

$679+

31' Dutchmen RV Atlas 2732RB

$139+

7-Nt Irish Opulence Vacation w/ Food Tours & Rental Car

$3342+

32' Thor Motor Coach Windsport 32N

$260+

Air & 9-Day Eastern Canada Tour | Save Up To $100

$2399+

10-Day Northern Europe | Pick Your Perk

$4199+

7-Day French Canal Barge Cruise | $1000 Off per Cabin

$3171+