If you’re looking for beautiful beaches, possible celebrity sightings, vineyards, and a fun getaway destination, then add Long Island, New York to the top of your list. Much more than just the suburbs of New York City, Long Island is easily accessible and has a lot to offer travelers seeking luxury and fun. There are also many excellent places to stay as you explore this borough, including these highly recommended Long Island hotels.


Look out for our newsletters in your inbox soon.

Montauk Manor, Montauk Exterior of Montauk Manor Resort
Exterior of Montauk Manor Resort

Montauk Manor, Montauk

Montauk Manor is east of the Hamptons and is situated on more than 12 acres of land with modern condo apartments. It has indoor and outdoor pools, a spa, meeting facilities, health club, tennis, and putting green for guests to use. This history of this resort dates back to the 1920s and offers guests a little more room to spread out with studio, deluxe, and three-bedroom apartments. You can dine onsite at La Fine Restaurant, which serves Northern and Southern Italian cuisine. Other amenities include a bocce court, shuffleboard court, basketball, picnic area, complimentary Wi-Fi, and courtesy van. Beyond the resort in Montauk, there are plenty of opportunities for hiking, biking, lighthouses, boating, and tours.

The Inn at Fox Hollow Hotel, Woodbury Overhead view of The Inn at Fox Hollow
Overhead view of The Inn at Fox Hollow

The Inn at Fox Hollow Hotel, Woodbury

The Inn at Fox Hollow Hotel is an all-suite Long Island hotel that has a heated outdoor pool, hot tub, and tropical courtyard. It also features a fitness center, lobby work station, and local shuttle service to locations within a 10-mile radius. Dine onsite with a complimentary American breakfast to start your day, and then enjoy the complimentary dinner buffet on Monday through Thursday evenings. The Volpe Restaurant & Lounge at Fox Hollow is open for dinner except for Sunday evenings, and you’ll find homemade cookies in the Hearth Room. In-room amenities include a wet bar and wine refrigerator in some rooms, robes and slippers, spa bathrooms, and kitchens with the essentials. This is a popular place for weddings and other special events.

Garden City Hotel, Garden City Garden City Hotel, Garden City
Garden City Hotel, Garden City

Garden City Hotel, Garden City

This luxury hotel has chic guest rooms and suites that are great for both business and leisure travel. It’s about 22 miles from Manhattan, offers complimentary Wi-Fi, has a seasonal patio bar, and is home to the Mynd Spa & Salon. The spa specializes in a wide range of massage, body treatments, skincare, and nail care. There’s also an indoor pool and fitness center here. Join a yoga class in the English garden on Saturday mornings. Pets are welcome here for a nightly fee and receive a bed, bowl, and treats. The Red Salt Room is David Burke’s restaurant that has creative signature dishes like pastrami salmon and cheesecake lollipops.

Oheka Castle Hotel & Estate, Huntington Oheka Castle Hotel & Estate, Huntington
Credit: oheka.com
Oheka Castle Hotel & Estate, Huntington

Oheka Castle Hotel & Estate, Huntington

Stay at this Long Island hotel for a historic experience that’s full of luxury and intrigue. The Oheka Castle Hotel & Estate is a Gold Coast mansion on the highest point on the island that is a favorite spot for weddings, New Year’s Eve celebrations, and other special occasions. There are unique guest rooms and suites here to stay in. Wine and dine at the OHK Bar & Restaurant run by Executive Chef Frank Monahan and Executive Pastry Chef Daniel Andreotti. You can also take a tour of this historic mansion for a small fee, while amenities at the castle include a fitness center and in-room massages.

Mill House Inn, East Hampton Mill House Inn, East Hampton
Mill House Inn, East Hampton

Mill House Inn, East Hampton

The Mill House Inn is a bed and breakfast hotel that welcomes couples, kids, and dogs. There are great local wineries to visit in this area, and you’ll enjoy the hospitality the inn offers. The inn has just 10 rooms and suites for an intimate feel. Each room is unique and has its own character. It even offers personal assistant services to help you book tickets and make reservations. The executive chef, Carolyn, serves an amazing breakfast.

Harborfront Inn, Greenport Pool at Harborfront Inn
Credit: Harborfront Inn
Pool at Harborfront Inn

Harborfront Inn, Greenport

Come to the Harborfront Inn to relax on Long Island’s North Fork and enjoy views of the bay. This inn has cozy guest rooms and suites with amenities that include Wi-Fi, plush bedding, and high-end bath products. Other perks are the complimentary continental breakfast, fitness room, outdoor heated pool, and all-day coffee service. You’ll be close to all the local wineries and downtown Greenport when you stay here.

Solé East Resort, Montauk Lawn at Solé East
Credit: Solé East
Lawn at Solé East

Solé East Resort, Montauk

This is another great option in Montauk if you’re looking for relaxation on the most eastern tip of Long Island. Come here to enjoy the region’s surfing, biking, sailing, fishing, and laid-back vibes. The Solé East Resort has bungalow-style rooms and garden cabana suites. Here you’ll also find a heated pool and be a five-minute walk from Montauk’s village and the beach. The Backyard Restaurant is onsite and serves all meals, including continental breakfast, brunch, and poolside fare.

Viana Hotel & Spa, Westbury Room at Viana Hotel & Spa
Room at Viana Hotel & Spa

Viana Hotel & Spa, Westbury

Viana Hotel & Spa offers a modern hotel and luxurious spa in a boutique, eco-friendly, and Feng Shui-based setting. Guests here enjoy the pool, hot tub, sauna, fitness center, steam room, game room, and full-service salon and spa. The spa is open daily and offers a wide range of services. Marco Polo’s Restaurant & Bar is onsite and has an eclectic menu of Italian-Asian fusion dishes.

Maidstone Hotel, East Hampton Dining area at The Maidstone
Dining area at The Maidstone

Maidstone Hotel, East Hampton

The Maidstone Hotel is an East Hampton gem that welcomes dogs and has a restaurant and bar onsite. It features elegant rooms and cottages that are decorated beautifully. The hotel was renovated in May 2017 and features a photo art collection and adheres to eco-friendly practices. Its history dates back over 150 years.

Allegria Hotel, Long Beach Room at Allegria Hotel
Credit: Allegria Hotel
Room at Allegria Hotel

Allegria Hotel, Long Beach

The oceanfront luxury at Allegria Hotel is perfect for a memorable getaway, offering a collection of beautiful guest rooms. Atlantica on the Ocean is the restaurant here that sits on the boardwalk. There’s a fitness center and rooftop pool here, and the beach is right outside too. The hotel concierge can hook you up with all the beach activities you crave, such as surfing, boating, fishing, volleyball, seasonal outdoor mini golf, seasonal flying trapeze, and ice skating in the winter.

You May Also Like
Top 9 Practical Hotels in New York City By KARYN WOFFORD | FEB 10, 2020